Friday, November 22, 2013

Entertainment, Entertainment and...



            When reading a finely detailed article in Caravan (read full article here) about how Arnab Goswami has changed (read corrupt) journalism in India, a completely different phenomenon struck my mind – the IPL. Searching the metaphysical links, I encountered the 100 crore club-member films, the so-called ‘reality’ shows, the saas-bahu sagas, the incessant twittering of many no-body’s, the agitators in Anna Hazaare’s movement, quotes of spokespersons of various political parties and even the parliament sessions. Boy! Have I touched subjects that I am little aware of? Who cares! As long as you are reading, I am good. As long as you are watching - the IPL, the sagas, the Dabanggs, the Goswamis will survive. As long as you are voting, the political parties will keep offering bull c**p through their spokespersons. And most importantly, as long as you voluntarily become actors in so-called agitations, the so-called democracy will survive. 

            The protagonist of The Dirty Picture, in that famous scene, proclaims that only three things matter in films – entertainment, entertainment and entertainment. Ironically (or may be purposely), the film offers nothing but entertainment. Veteran actor Naseeruddin Shah mentioned in an interview that films do not and cannot change anything in the society. Their purpose is only entertainment. Does this apply to literature too? After all, films are founded on a literary form – script. If you visit a road-side book-wallah with the paper-backs, you see many Chetan Bhagats emerging out of the modern, corporate India. Titles like When I Met Her, Love over Coffee contain more or less an amalgam of what has been bred in us through films, especially those of the ‘90s. Why many read and enjoy them is another matter but what are our inspirations is the real question. Our romanticism about love and even about society being challenged by an angry young man has always been there. It is not a novel trend that we love our action heroes these days. As a society, we always have loved to let one man have all the power and rely for our survival solely on him (rarely on a her, like Indira Gandhi, too).

It is probably this laziness that prompts us to let others formulate even opinions for us. So impressed are we with TV news anchors’ animated attacks on government, activists and their own guests, that we never bother to realise that the details of a news are never served. One line of breaking news is enough to spark fire in these self-proclaimed opinion makers to jump start discussions about how our country is a sinking ship. All we receive at the end of it is anger, probably even inspiration that is as momentary as that of the agitators in Anna’s movement. This fruitless inspiration is probably the most well disguised form of entertainment. And this is the kind of entertainment news channels cash upon. Whether opinion and news should be mixed is an argument that has a long history and we probably have even forgotten the difference. The article mentioned above brings to fore the more unsettling reality of news being even altered for the purpose of TRPs. Needless to say that a high TRP – a representative of popularity requires a high entertainment quotient; it doesn’t matter if the news channel presents news or anything else, as long as it entertains.

Look at the TV coverage in the last weeks leading to Sachin Tendulkar’s retirement and you will realise how the two factors of hero-worship and media hype come together. Being a hardcore Rahul Dravid fan, even I cried about why the man did not receive a similar farewell. But looking absolutely, why has Tendulkar been subject of such a grand exit? Creating fewer enemies, I agree that Sachin deserves it; the question is what propagated him to the level of a demi-god?  His class, his statistics, his dedication…yes, everything, but above all the fact that he entertained us. I respect those who appreciate the beauty of his stance or that of his follow-through, but weren’t we crazy after the sixes he hit coming down the pitch and lost interest when he became more subdued and shrewd after his injuries? 

Coming to a larger point, I do not belittle our need for entertainment. But does entertainment mean an escape from reality? Taking examples from two of the most popular phenomena in India – Cricket and Cinema, it definitely appears to be so. Aristotle defined Catharsis – a way of purification of emotions through the experience of grief in a tragedy. He wrote this in the 4th century Before Christ. Times have changed but have tragedies in real life receded. Has our need to cry and let it go finished? We do it once in a while after many shots of Tequila or in a pretentious affair like Barfi. But let us learn to differentiate between romanticism and catharsis. It hurts when a genuine piece of art like Anumati flops. Or when IPL transforms from mere entertainment to serious cricket to make Tests boring and defence a taboo. IPL is not just serious cricket but serious money and boundless power now where Bollywood and politics have come to fore with alarming amounts of investments.

As I said, entertainment is a necessity. Films and cricket may and probably should do that. But isn't it an overdose when news, social agitations and politics become its devices? In how many fields does politics interfere is a topic of a separate post. There are more important entities like power and money involved there. And frankly, the analysis of their strategies is beyond my capacities. All I know is I am amused by their quotes and speeches and that there is a scope there for a lot of sarcasm there. We are often told how one vote matters and how we can overthrow an undeserving government through that power. In a democracy where we only get to choose a local representative, whose loyalty can swing with a khookaa here and there and impotent enhancements like NOTA– the day is not far when the whole exercise of election will be a form of entertainment for our rulers.