A quiet,
understated pain fills the visuals, and the silences, of the Gajendra Ahire film.
Seldom, a long, screeching scream vents it out.
There is a breed of men that
finds relief in melancholy. Popularly known as romantics, they are usually
heartbroken with the realities of life. Day after day, affected by empathy,
powerlessness and futility, they accept sorrow as the mainstay of human heart.
They express it through their brooding – they weave stories, songs, paintings…everything
that can give some shape to the shapeless ache in their being. It transcends to
art when the narrator finds a form, a true, subjective voice.
Gajendra Ahire, in an interview, told me that “when a story is spurred, the film should be on the material in-built in it”. Probably that is why, he never takes the pain of a woman for a granted. Be it Not Only Mrs. Raut or Shewri, he gives his female characters a very real, hard-hitting backstory. And probably that is why, The Silence broods under unspoken words, long, painful screams and dark, distorted visuals. It is not something a woman speaks of openly. And it is not something a man can bear.
Chini, a reclusive, quiet
young girl is travelling in a local train late at night. When she sees another
young girl being abused, she suffers a panic attack. Memories come back to her –
her quaint village, her drunkard but kind-hearted father, the abusive, vile maama
and the repressed, lonely maami – all appear in flashbacks. Her own
12-year old self is caught among these people and the circumstances.
What happens is pretty
predictable. And as Indian audiences, we expect shocking moments, violent
revenges and some voyeurism to go with it. However, that is not the point of
the film. Right from the point when the motherless Chini gets her first period -
to when she is abused - to when the maami finds out - to when Chini is
reproducing the event during investigation – no explicit scenes or sentences
are used. It is visuals and sounds (and silences) that convey the story.
In the scene where she is
abused, the sound of a toy is used to indicate the violation of innocence. Quite
typical, some would say. But when the grown-up Cheeni wakes up to the same
sound in her dreams, it forces you to be startled. In the investigation scene,
the child is half-seen through a glass of water – half her face is intact,
while half of it is distorted. It is the maami and the father who scream
for her. But Cheeni’s silence is persistent – until she speaks up for the other
lady on the local train.
The maami has her own
story to tell. She haunts a small house with the curse of being infertile. She
sits at the window all day hearing a baby in the neighbourhood. When her
husband whips her for not cooking, her agony finds a voice, but not relief.
When he wants to consume her, she is dead as a stone. Shadows, darkness, narrow
stretches of light are woven around her. It is finally in complete darkness
that she executes her revenge.
The film would have been hardly anyone’s pick for the weekend. In the theatre I watched it, there were about 15 people. And many of them laughed at Nagraj Manjule’s rustic dialect. The dialogues do give an unreal feel. And like in many of Ahire’s films, the locations and the timeline can confuse you. There's a patchy side-story of Cheeni's sister.
But all this is hardly the point of the film. It is the mood – a quiet, understated pain – that fills you. Kudos to writer Ashwini Sidwani for giving it a voice.
