My interest in the topic began when, in an actors’discussion, two important points of view came up. Actor Parvathy opined that
the ultimate “messaging” of the film matters; if a film glorifies patriarchy in
any way, she refuses to work in such films. On the other hand, Manoj Bajpayee
said that he doesn’t care about the messaging and a film should primarily be “engaging”.
In another interview, he substantiated his argument saying we should not
“burden” characters with our morality and he will play characters if he his
convinced with the “realism of the script”.
The debate now centres on something else – apparently between
the depiction of reality in a work of art and the ideology it upholds. Bajpayee
and in fact many others seem to be asking that if it’s real, why can’t it be
shown? Further, if it’s real, why burden it with “morality”? The reason they give for the latter is that the audience will anyway take it in different ways,
which is a point I would agree with partially. But the larger point implicit in
“not burdening” a work of art with “morality” seems to be that a work of art is
or can be devoid of ideology. This is a point that I intend to contest.
My entry point to Kabir Singh were two rather
profound quotes at the beginning of the narrative – “suffering is a very
personal thing” and “if you go too deep into something, all you get is a zero”.
Absolute gold for a brooding romantic and pretentious nihilist! But when you
take off on such a high plane, you have created a curiosity in your audience as
to what brought the narrative to this great conclusion? Enter Kabir
Singh, a college macho who wins football matches for his college, tops the
exams, offering some bad-assery alongside. After almost admiring his theatrics,
I was interested in the “great” love story. Enter Preeti, the demure, almost
dumb heroine, who refuses to say anything, even to look directly in the hero’s
eyes. Kabir just sees her and declares “ye meri bandi hai” (she is my girl)
– not just to himself or his friends, but to the entire college. The guy goes
on to bring her in his boys’ hostel room, keep her there, sleep with her, drop
her for her exam and while at that, asks her to drape her pallu “appropriately”.
In none of these incidents does Preeti speak more than a few words.
The question now is, since there is no conversation
between the two, from what place does this “love” arise in Kabir’s heart? It is
not that I don’t believe in a sudden surge of feelings. But even that has a
place from which it arises, hooks of details are there which stimulate your interpretation. Like in Rockstar, Janardan’s family
background and lack of ambition tells you that he is severely deprived of love
and any sense of purpose. In Heer, he sees the promise of both. Or in Bajirao
Mastani, the titular characters are locked in a fierce, life-testing
situation (a battle) that is conducive for generating passionate feelings.
Kabir has none of this. Literally everything is in his favour; his family, his
friends, even his college principal look at him almost admiringly – he’s a
brat, but he’s great at everything, seems to be the general notion.
It is safe to assume then, that the film (Kabir
Singh) thinks that a “dashing”, bratty, “macho” manchild and a demure, shy,
girl (who knows how to drape her pallu) are a perfect match. No other
circumstances are required to define their feelings, nothing else is needed to stimulate
the audience’s interpretation. In other words, we are left to define their love
entirely by some generic standards. And what’s more generic than gender
stereotypes! The desire of a man’s authority over a girl’s body is fulfilled to
such an extent in the film that when Kabir finally finds Preeti after her
marriage, she is pregnant and whose is the child? Bingo – Kabir’s. Her husband
didn’t get a chance to touch her and her “purity” is intact!
It is in this context of male authority over “his”
girl’s body that we need to place director Vanga’s statement – “if you can’t
slap… touch your woman wherever you want…I don’t see emotion there”. This is
the idea that prevails through the film. The ideology of the film, knowingly or
unknowingly, stems from this thought. And whether Bajpayee and others identify
it or not, every piece of art come from a place of (vague or refined) ideology.
It might be worth to examine another work from a
totally different era and see if the argument really works. The Pastor’s
Wife by Elizabeth von Arnim is, for me, a hidden gem in English literature.
Published in 1914 and set in contemporary times, the novel tells the story of
Ingeborg, an English girl who, in a moment of impulse, gets married to a pastor
and goes to live with him in Prussia. Her impulse is driven by the desire to
set herself free from the reins of an orthodox father who is a bishop. What she
discovers at her new home, is the same hierarchy; additionally, now she is
expected to produce children after children while handling domestic duties.
von Arnim and her texts are not seen, at least
traditionally, as feminist. In the book Elizabeth von Arnim: Beyond the
German Garden, Isobel Maddison mentions that the writer “creates a complex
interpretative space through which gendered norms are challenged…underscores
the performance of gender by…satirising the ideals of ‘femininity’”.
While the terms used here are indeed from feminist discourses, Maddison goes on
to say “…von Arnim would probably have rejected this label”. Wikipedia mentions
that in the reception of her work, she was seen as “a sort of feminist”. She
can probably be placed in New Woman figure of the late nineteenth century and some researches do do that, but
pages about the movement seem to be rarely mentioning her.
Frankly, it is useless and even unfair to label
someone without themselves doing so. What is useful, however, is looking
closely at what emerges from the text. In The Pastor’s Wife, Ingeborg is
being pressured by her husband and the society around, that it is her duty to
have children. An authoritative baroness in Prussia tells her that “…every true
woman loves children”. Being a woman is thus, as in many societies, arbitrarily
connected to motherhood. The problem of authority over her body comes up when
it is quite clear that she is not able to physically cope with the stress of
pregnancy and childbirth. She is still expected to carry on with this “career”
as there is no other way she can exist. After having six children in seven years as “one
child after the other sapped her up”, she finally confronts her husband and
tells him that she is unwilling to carry on like this. The pastor completely fails
to understand the point. When she refers to herself a “battered thing on a sofa”,
he replies in astonishment, “you call a wife and a mother engaged in carrying
out her obligations a battered thing on a sofa?” (my italics).
Call von Arnim and her texts feminist or not, the idea
of authority of a woman over her body emerges from the text constantly. In
fact, bodily health itself finds way in the narrative in several places. In a
beautiful segment, Ingeborg is just herself while she roams in the woods of
Prussia and appreciates the beauty around as her body becomes “light and
perfectly balanced”. After she declares retirement from her “career” of
pregnancy and childbirth, her cheeks start flushing and she finally sleeps a
sound sleep. Contrarily, her husband finds it difficult to name this new relationship
with her, and in his mind, starts considering her a sister. Again, without the
ownership of her body, he is not able to see her as his wife.
This is not to say that The Pastor’s Wife is
devoid of other themes. But the primary issue remains the freedom Ingeborg is
seeking and its connection with the control over her own body. Without any
formal labels, this ideology is still apparent in the text.
Bajpayee and others are, as said before, partially correct in pointing out that audience will interpret art in their own ways. But it must be remembered that it is not just the ideology of a work of art that steers the interpretation, but also the personal ideology of the audiences/readers. In the case of Kabir Singh, those who sit at the top of the gender hierarchy will find it “normal”, those fighting the hierarchy everyday will be uncomfortable. So, as assumed by those defending the film, the call is not for banning any work of art, but understanding and accommodating criticism.
P.S.: Kabir Singh is now shown on TV with the slapping scene shown repetitively in the promos. The more you talk about it, the more it becomes a marketing point. That is a slap on your faces, you "libtard feminazis"!
