Monday, April 4, 2016

Voice of a Rebel

April 9, 2015

Shahir Sambhaji Bhagat, the composer of Court, sings songs that speak of angst, humiliation and reforms. It is an evening when a rebellion is voiced and percolated

‘How can I write, with authority, about something which I have loved but understood so feebly!’ says Vijay Tendulkar in the foreword to Namdev Dhasal’s poetry collection Golpeetha. I have no intention of comparing myself to the genius of Tendulkar, but yes, I am in a similar predicament. For the first time, I am not sure if I have understood what I saw. I am probably incapable of identifying with a sensitivity that is so deeply rooted in a history of oppression and injustice. But I am going to try. Not so that I can yet again proclaim that I am a writer, but because this is important enough to be told.

The occasion was the promotion of the National Award winning film Court. The man at the helm was the film’s music composer Shahir Sambhaji Bhagat – a poet, singer, playwright and more importantly, an Ambedkarist. The last trait makes him a ‘rebel’, to speak in conventional terms, and that reflects in every facet of his art. His songs are full of angst against the establishment and the discourses in between are marked with a scathing satire.

“Aur kitne di andhere me rahoge bhai...” he asks as he sees that the audiences’ part of the Balgandharva Auditorium in dark. “Genuine art takes you towards reality,” he says. You realise the fight is not just against a caste system and its atrocities, but against all its implications. Bhagat’s first song breaks some longstanding stereotypes in art. ‘He palkhiche bhoi...yanna aai chi olakh naahi...’ is a direct attack on the classic by poet Shankar Vaidya - ‘Palkhiche bhoi amhi...palkhit kon, aamha pusayache naahi...’  

“Why should the bearer not ask who is in the palanquin? We will ask who it is, what is their purpose, what is their position!” he says. He throws off the submissive stand of the original song to propose a more defiant one.  He also denounces the ever-praised romantic nature poetry. “No one is closer to nature than us. I have lived in Jawali, Mahabaleshwar and love the land. But children die there of diarrhoea, ignored,” he says.

The group has much more in store. Apart from Bhagat, all of them are young. They are educated and have complete awareness of what they are and where they want to go. Somewhere, you sense a change of hands in the movement. Bhagat speaks about all of them with warmth. “They have dedicated themselves to the movement,” he says.

The words of the songs, the depth of the voices get darker as the show progresses. There’s the reverential mention of Bheema in almost every song. Events like the ‘Mahad Lake Satyagraha’ make appearances. A line like ‘Kaalya aaichya uraat...Bheem lekhnya perto’ might sound hyperbole-ish, but it carries a huge meaning when you realise the revolution Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar and consequently education has brought amongst the Dalits. There is also introspection and comment on Dalit leaders who, the songs say, are mellowed when offered political power. ‘Sattet miltaa waata..talwar myaan maajhi..’ a song goes.

Bhagat also praises Court’s makers – director Chaitanya Tamhane and producer, actor Vivek Gomber. “The music I composed initially was popular folk. Chaitanya didn’t want that. We then explored music that has been hidden for years. You will see glimpses of folk from North Indian, Maharashtrian and South Indian in a song. Another song is completely Marathi,” he explained.

The event also digressed to interview actors Geetanjali Kulkani and Vira Sathidar. Sathidar, himself an activist, said the role wasn’t difficult for him. The film tells the story of Narayan Kamble (Sathidar’s character) who is a folk singer and gets trapped in a false court case for inciting suicide. “Narayan Kamble is not the first one. Annabhau Sathe, Vamandada Kardak, Vilas Ghogare all have gone through the same,” he said.

Commenting on her character of a public prosecutor, Kulkarni said that she represents the typical middle-class mentality. “She does not have a larger perspective of life. A calculated life, family, children and doing job without sensitivity is all she knows,” she said.

The most striking parts of the program were the monologues of Bhagat in between the songs. There was humour, satire but above all, a deep sense of humiliation and rebellion against it. There is also a voice of a social reformer. He comments on social insensitivity tapping on topics like Kharda murder case, on the economical lineation saying ‘cyber capitalism is the new capitalism’ and fascist tendencies.

Against the ‘cash for vote’ practice, he says, wo setting karte hain, hum voting karte hai...people laugh. But then he adds something that leaves everyone thinking, “Dr. Ambedkar said in his constitutional speech that the constitution gives political equality to a country that does not have financial and social equality. The day votes are sold, democracy will end.”   


Against Indignation

October 10, 2014

Internalise the indignation. Let it show in your eyes, imbibe it in your spine, says Chandralekha. The veteran dancer spoke at a crucial moment in Director Eil Lall’s film Sharira. In a way, she summarised what the other three films of the morning - La Chambre, Mujer Ante El Espejo and Pas De Deux, said more implicitly.

The films were part of the first session of The Feminine Lens, a film festival organised by Women in Film and Television (WIFT). On October 10, the two-day festival was inaugurated by senior filmmaker Aruna Raje at the National Film Archives of India (NFAI). Film scholar and curator of the festival Gayatri Chatterjee, NFAI director Alpana Pant Sharma and FTII Outreach advisor Shabnam Sukhdev were present on the occasion.

As Chatterjee put it, the films at the opening session were focused on dancing, because the intent was to make the beginning celebratory. And Ballet turned out to be the form that at a time conveyed the angst and defined the expression of freedom in women.

The French film La Chambre/The Room did it with masterful symbolism. It showed a group of ballerinas stuck in a room and hearing the waves, the winds on the sea. While the sounds conveyed the storm in their hearts, their dance poses showed what their bodies were suffering – an entrapment. With beautiful synchronisations, director duo Joelle Bouvier and Regis Obadia captured the uniformity and universality of the suffering.

This was followed by a Cuban documentary Mujer Ante El Espejo/Woman in Front of the Mirror by director Marisol Trujillo. It showed another ballerina’s struggle, more directly this time, caught between pregnancy and her career. She wants both and succeeds in balancing it, completely on her own.

Noted filmmaker Sandhya Gokhale, who was in the audience, commented in the later discussion about the film – “I liked the way she dealt with the situation without any help from her husband. In fact, the absence of help was not even lamented about. He was given no significance and she didn’t expect anything from him.”  Chatterjee observed regarding this point that it was in fact a point of criticism for the film. “It was expressed that the film ducked the point altogether. As a larger picture, Cuba could never get rid of its patriarchy,” she said.

Director Norman McLaren’s film Pax De Deux was another staggering experience. It used technology effectively to show a woman dancing with herself – through two images of her performing steps one after the other. A man then joins her and multiple images spur through them. It was Chatterjee again who explained it minutely – “The woman is a narcissist and the man loves her. 
The theme is of couple formation, that dance requires two people.”

Prior to the screening, Raje shared her experiences as a woman in the film industry. “The medium of films has always been denying to women. When I went to Mumbai after completing film education in FTII, people questioned – ‘ladki kya kar rhi hai yahan (what’s a girl doing in direction.) She should be in front of the camera.’ But I have continued behind the camera for the last 37 years,” she said. Raje has made acclaimed films like Shaque, Gehraai, Sitam, Rihaee and Bhairavi.


The festival will continue on October 11. It has offerings from Czechoslovakia, USA, Iran, India and films by students of FTII.  

Monday, March 28, 2016

Backyard: The Microcosm of Isolation

It was as if there was no corner for him in the house. His father was smoking in the hall; the bedroom was too full with sunlight; the backroom was crammed with overdone furniture, books and drying clothes and the kitchen (which wasn’t an option anyway) smelled of flowery incense sticks his mother had burnt up for her pooja.

He himself needed a cigarette. ‘It has been only fifteen minutes since I woke up,’ he said to himself, looking blankly at the fading wall clock in the hall and trying to trace the already long trail of his thoughts.

 There were too many of them with too little order – Hinduism, Hijacking Ambedkar, Fascism… - seeming branches of the same problem but without any purpose or direction. Just a whirlwind of distress making rounds in a tiny, enclosed box.

He pitied his mind. He knew this was just an outer layer. The real issue was that he himself was not at peace from inside, with no apparent reason. He pitied his inability to part away from the chaos on one side and his timidity in remaining sane on the other. He kept going to and fro in the hall, his father partly ignoring, partly watching with detached curiosity.

‘Cigarette!’ he yearned for it again, hopelessly. Coffee was the next best drug. But his mother won’t budge. There was still no sound of the ghanti which would notify the end of the long procedure. Neither could he himself make a cup. Touching the cooking space before a bath would mean blasphemy.

He resorted to the backyard, an annexure to the kitchen, which was still quite cool as a neighbouring bungalow had hid the sun. From the same building, he could hear (like every morning) loud chants of ‘Hare Krishna, Hare Rama’. He feared this would agitate him further now. But surprisingly, the initial impression of calm, when he stepped into the yard, had settled in and he could ignore the noise.

 ‘The pleasures of a bungalow!’ he thought, unsympathetically remembering his hostel room. He had desperately thought of cutting his visit short and to return to his hostel a while ago. (Yes, the boys there were fanatics too, but at least they are shallow enough to be entertainers. ‘Haughty!’ he then thought of himself.) A whiff of chafa, the sweet smelling white-yellow flower planted in the neighbouring yard, erased that thought completely. He immediately fetched a book.

The backyard was also where his mother would usually serve him breakfast during his days of visit home. He suddenly realised he was hungry. He peeped into the kitchen to find his mother deeply drowned in a spiritual chant (only, hers was in whispers). He couldn’t frown much over this though. He could hardly cook. He smiled sheepishly at his situation.



Refreshed, he still approached his book with hesitation. He loved Pamuk. For the way in which his narrators indulged in their thoughts, their walks in desolated Turkish cities, a sense of lost belonging and social observations weaved in all along with so much ease, so much a part of the individual’s narrative.

He was scared he would miss all those details in the current mood. But there seemed to be no other way. He dully read through the first two pages which he was reading probably the third time now. The old lady, her young servant and the former’s irritating behaviour seen from the perspective of the latter...

The ghanti finally rang. With guilt that was so obvious yet so innocently hidden under her pride, his mother asked him if he needed anything. ‘Black coffee,’ he said wearing a conscious expression of aloofness. Though it was almost lost now, he must convey his earlier feeling of anguish, he thought.

‘Do you need it with lemon? Is your stomach upset?’ she asked. She always had had this ability to view problems in a completely material order. Last year, he had told her repeatedly, and with a trace of expectant sympathy, that he was suffering from depression. But her sole diagnosis was that he lacked a sleep and meal timetable and subjected his body to no exercise. Hell, it proved right and the problem vanished when he practised yoga for just fifteen days.

He often compared Manasvi to his mother. Her conservatism, belief in the occult, idol worship...were all on similar lines with his mother. But he thought she would 'evolve' (and then he would confess his feeling for her). But when she said, ‘Sanskriti is just a way of life’ and not ‘a system of oppression’ as he believed it to be, he gave up the pursuit. (Not to assume she would be interested anyway.)

He delved back into the book. As the unread portion began, a new world seemed to unfold before him.  Characters, city, society, country started to rise out of the pages. His sense of detachment from his surroundings and transformation into a completely different world, grew sharply. He thought all he needed now was a deep, striking quote that would bring him back to life. But this was Pamuk, no Wilde or Coelho. There was just the feel – a quiet night, a cool sea wind and discrete patches of life around his narrator...he knew he would be hooked for a few months now.   

For now, he closed the book. And stared into the shadow, which was receding as the sun rose from behind the building. Intermittent gushes of breeze made him lighter. It was soothingly quiet. An ant bit his foot and he thought, ‘How natural!’ He effortlessly rose and picked up a chafa flower and smelled it deeply. As if taking a drag of tobacco. The universe had merged, he thought, into the microcosm of the backyard.

Chants of ‘Hare Krishna, Hare Rama’ aroused again from the neighbourhood. He noticed he hadn’t heard them for a while.