For the Palaks more than the Balaks
It is very difficult to watch a movie when it reminds you of another one. I had to put in a lot of effort for the first 10-15 minutes of Balak Palak; the strong impression of Shaala was hampering my current experience.
In those first minutes I noticed BP was more articulate than Shaala, its characters very specifically defined but less adorable and its nostalgia very scarcely identifiable.
The film talks about the growing years of four teenagers - two boys and two girls, and their exposure to the world of erotica through a fifth funny-and-spoilt friend.
The characters are introduced through a short description by a voice-over by Amruta Subhash (also starring in a cameo). Thankfully, the characters did not keep on doing the same thing described at their entry through the film
. The shades of all of them are nicely covered and the transformations these teenagers experience are epitomized very subtly - a guy falling for a much older hottie (Sai Tamhankar) in the chawl, another one falling in love with a girl in the group and the second girl completely hating the changing nature of friendship in the group.
It is also very pleasant to see the characters of Sai Tamhankar and Kishor Kadam - an elder to even the parents in the chawl, emerging to resolve the situation when we are expecting a typical parents-should-give-sex-education-to-pupils end.
But my first impression served me right. The film was extremely articulate sketching each event and each dialogue very carefully. Articulation in art can be very risky. It bars the natural flow of a story and kills the viewer's experience as artificiality creeps in. BP does not sink that low but it is unsettling to be in such a water-tight premise. I was also baffled by the gimmick of taking us into the flashback. With a topic like teens getting attracted to erotic literature, so much could have been portrayed in the current scenario of computers and the internet. Instead, we are time-travelled to 1983 when the only material was sleazy books and VCR cassettes. Is this a personal memoir or just an attempt to refresh our Shaala memories?
The message gets across brilliantly though as all the parents (in the film) remain unaware of the whole story. It tells very subtly to those in the audiences - wake up!
No comments:
Post a Comment