‘I have sold my soul to
the devil!’ Mahesh Bhatt yelled at a lady in a heated argument of the Star
World show ‘Love to Hate You’. The lady ‘hater’ asked him why doesn't he simply
make porn movies instead of making the Jisms and the Murders? Amongst other accusations Bhatt saab faces in society is infusing
Pakistani talent in Bollywood, for his secular stands and his criticism of the
Hindu extremists. ‘Why is he so obsessed with the Muslims?’ one of my friends commented. I defended giving details of his childhood
and reminded him of the story of Zakhm. I also tried to remind him that
India is, at least constitutionally, a secular state. All that went into vain,
obviously.
I thought is this why
Bhatt saab quit direction? Because no one, rather very few, understood
him? He very arrogantly says that he makes movies for money. Period. But then
why would have Arth or Saaraansh happened? He does churn a lot of
money now with the commercial products. And he does tease you saying that
people do buy these products. Whatever you call him – a soft porn maker, a
loud-mouth or even a Pakistani, the agony for his critics is you will never get
the satisfaction of blaming him. He will easily accept all those things you
say.
But the fact is that I
miss Mahesh Bhatt – the director, very badly! I have adolescent memories of the
haunting, nostalgic tunes of ‘tere dar par sanam’ and ‘tu meri
zindagi hain’. I still freeze with shock when I remember the moment when
the mother in Zakhm reveals to her son that she is a Muslim. The shock
melts down into a melancholy of anger, sympathy, helplessness…towards our
social, religious, national structure. I still love Aamir and Pooja dancing to
‘Hum hain raahi pyaar ke hum se kuchh na boliye..’ - Aamir with his cap on his head and an unlit
cigarette in his mouth. Consequently I miss the combo of Bhatt saab and
Aamir. Consequently, I miss Bhatt saab and those melodious tunes, Bhatt saab
and the strong statements in his films, Bhatt saab and Naseeruddin
Shah, Bhatt saab and Paresh Rawal, Bhatt saab and the agony, the
self-expression, the sensitivity, the beauty, even the sensuousness…
What went wrong? Where
did it go wrong? His works have always been accused of being stolen; even the
music of his films. He simply returned the ball saying ‘everything in the world
is inspired’. It was and is true. While Dil Hain Ki Maanta Nahin was a
copy of It Happened One Night, it still had a Bhatt signature and a lot
of his heart (Signature and heart are really weak arguments but his fans would
know what I am saying).Today he makes irrelevant sequels where the first part
is a copy of Unfaithful – an American film and the second part is a copy
of The Chaser – a Korean Movie (Murder and Murder 2).
Bhatt saab would not agree that this is degradation. But even if he
does, what is the use? He is merely doing business now. Rather, he always did. Aashiqui
involved a research on the trend of movies at the time and targeted the
youth. And even with ‘inspired’ tunes (like many others) by Nadeem Shravan, the
film did capture the youth’s hearts. Bhatt saab might argue that romance
was a sellable commodity then, today its sex! And you have to agree to that.
Although it is the
Bhatt camp (Vishesh films) that made sex in Hindi cinema more bold. Actors,
even in a Karan Johar movie, dare to kiss on screen today because Emran Hashmee
kissed (and continues to kiss) so many ladies on screen. It was Bhatt saab’s
leading lady (in Jism, a copy of Basic Instincts) who said ‘yeh
jism pyaar nahin sirf bhook jaanta hain’. Was he trying to sell sex even
then? I doubt. It was an expression of the sexual desires in women, though in a
copied story and a bad movie. Today, his characters indulge in sex not because
of jism’s bhook, but because the films are in a shadow of one another.
And because they do so well commercially. Another friend of mine said why
doesn’t he launch Alia Bhatt in one of his hyper-sexual films? Well, he had
Pooja kiss her hero in Phir Teri Kahaani Yaad Aayi (in 1992!). The
point is that somewhere those moments have lost their innocence. The pain, the
restlessness his characters used to carry is no more calmed like that of Naseeruddin
Shah of Sir who tries to pacify gang-wars and finds peace in helping his
students creating beautiful relationships along the way. Today, they turn
to physical relationships only. An attempt to resurrect was done in Awaarapan
(another copy), where a haunted Shivam, guilty of accidentally killing
his beloved, tries to liberate himself by helping a girl flee from a gangster’s
hold. Mohit Suri’s bad direction ruined it.
Is it the dearth of
creativity in the Bhatt camp? Mohit Suri is definitely a supporting example for
a ‘yes’ as answer (And that he is directing Aashiqui 2 is bad news). But
with Anurag Basu, Kangana Ranawat and Rahat Fateh Ali Khan, Bhatt saab’s eye-for-talent
still seems to be intact. It was Jism that saw Vinay Pathak and Ranvir
Shorey in important roles for the first time. Or more importantly Manoj
Bajpayee and Ashutosh Rana in Bhatt camp’s tele-serial Swaabhimaan. Unfortunately,
its present scenario is hopeless. As Sudhish Kamath, summarized in his Murder 2
review for The Hindu – ‘Imagine the level of creative impotence when one of
the best films of last decade –The Chaser – is blatantly ripped off almost
scene by scene and is still unable to stir a single emotion.’
Reading between my own
lines, I discover that though Bhatt saab says he has sold his soul, he
yells while saying that, he is enraged. Back in the 90s, he had found success
with the formula of ripping-off films intelligently with Dil Hai Ki Maanta
Nahi and Hum Hai Raahi Pyaar Ke. He went back to a super-flop yet
disturbing story of a eunuch and his adopted daughter in Tamanna and to
a controversial biography – the sublime Zakhm. And though Aasiqui was
backed by market research, it was a nostalgic expression. Another accusation on
him, rather a point that is made fun of, in Sanjay Bhansali’s words – ‘he has
an opinion on anything and everything.’ I want to believe that Bhatt saab is
still restless about everything that happens around us. That it would someday
inspire him again to make a film. With haunting tunes, with ‘human’ characters
and with an original story narrated in a way that only he can.
Nice Article Praveen.. Keep it up.. Good going.. All the Best..!!!
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot Sumesh!
DeleteLiked it, agreed on many points..
ReplyDeleteYeah, it's really disturbing to see this downfall of a person who has once made some sensible stuff, though ripped off or "inspired" or whatever you call it, but just showed the world what he is(?) capable of..
Even RGV falls under the same category of such filmmakers, the reasons in his case are certainly different though.
A few movies that I had watched a long back and that have stayed in my heart were directed by Mahesh Bhatt. But I never knew this. Whenever I used to see Bhatt on TV I wondered what good this dude is. Reading what you've written I think now I know why I felt this way
ReplyDelete